Skip to content

Appeals Committee - 20 October 2025

Appeals Committee·

Key Takeaways

  • Councillor O’Keefe was elected Chairman of the meeting.
  • The minutes of the Appeals Committee meetings on 26 September 2025 and 6 October 2025 were approved and signed by the Chairman.
  • The meeting was closed to press and public for certain agenda items to protect exempt personal information.
  • Travel assistance requests for pupils to attend St Columb Major Academy (Bodmin), Callington Community College (Liskeard), Pool Academy (Camborne), and Poltair School (near St Austell) were all refused.
  • A travel assistance request for a pupil to attend Cape Cornwall School (ARB) from Hayle was approved.
AI-Generated Summary

This summary was generated by AI and may contain errors. Read the full minutes for the official record.

**Election of Chairman and procedural approvals**

The meeting opened with a motion moved by Councillor Clegg and seconded by Councillor Wilson to elect Councillor O’Keefe as Chairman for the session. The motion was carried without objection. No declarations of interest were recorded. Subsequent motions moved by Councillor O’Keefe and seconded by Councillor Clegg approved the minutes of the Appeals Committee meetings held on 26 September 2025 and 6 October 2025, with both sets of minutes to be signed by the Chairman.

**Exclusion of press and public**

A motion was put forward by Councillor O’Keefe, seconded by Councillor Clegg, to exclude the press and public from the consideration of a specific item of business under the Local Government Act 1972 (as amended). The exclusion was justified on the basis that the discussion would likely involve the disclosure of exempt information relating to an individual whose parent had withdrawn an appeal. The motion was resolved in favour of exclusion.

**Travel‑assistance requests – refusals**

The council considered several requests for travel assistance for pupils commuting to schools outside their residential area. Motions to refuse assistance for a pupil travelling from Bodmin to St Columb Major Academy were moved by Councillor O’Keefe and seconded by Councillor Wilson; the motion was adopted. A similar request for a pupil travelling from Liskeard to Callington Community College was moved by Councillor Clegg and seconded by Councillor Wilson and also refused. Additional refusals were passed for pupils travelling from Camborne to Pool Academy and from near St Austell to Poltair School, both motions moved by Councillor O’Keefe and seconded by Councillor Clegg.

**Travel‑assistance request – approval**

One request was approved: a pupil travelling from Hayle to Cape Cornwall School (ARB). The motion to allow the travel assistance was moved by Councillor Clegg and seconded by Councillor Wilson, and the council resolved to grant the assistance. No other items were addressed in the meeting.

Attendance

4 of 5 members present

Decisions

Election of Chairman O’Keefe

The council voted to elect Councillor O’Keefe as chairman for the meeting.

Carried

Approval of Appeals Committee minutes (26 Sep 2025)

The council agreed that the Appeals Committee’s minutes from 26 September 2025 are accurate and should be signed by the Chairman.

Carried

Approval of Appeals Committee minutes (6 Oct 2025)

The council approved the minutes of the Appeals Committee meeting on 6 October 2025, confirming they were accurate and should be signed by the chairman.

Carried

Exclusion of press and public during certain business

The council voted to keep the press and public out of the meeting when discussing matters that may contain exempt information.

Carried

Refusal of travel assistance for pupil to St Columb Major Academy

The council has refused to provide travel assistance for a student from Bodmin who wants to attend St Columb Major Academy.

Rejected

Refusal of travel assistance for pupil to Callington Community College

The council decided to deny travel assistance for the student who wants to travel from Liskeard to Callington Community College.

Rejected

Approval of travel assistance for pupil to Cape Cornwall School (ARB)

The council approved travel assistance for a pupil from Hayle to attend Cape Cornwall School.

Approved

Refusal of travel assistance for pupil to Pool Academy

The council voted to reject the request for travel assistance for a Camborne pupil who wants to attend Pool Academy.

Rejected

Refusal of travel assistance for pupil to Poltair School

The council voted to deny travel assistance for a student who lives near St Austell and wants to attend Poltair School.

Rejected

Adjacent Appeals Committee meetings: