Miscellaneous Licensing Committee - 12 September 2025
Key Takeaways
- •The meeting minutes were corrected to show a start time of 10:30 am and were resolved to be signed by the Chairman.
- •The press and public were excluded from consideration of certain business to protect exempt information.
- •Applications for Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Driver’s Licences from WD207 and WD209 were both refused as the committee deemed them not fit and proper persons.
- •The renewal of CD287’s Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Driver’s Licence was approved, pending satisfactory stress echocardiogram and myocardial perfusion scan results.
This summary was generated by AI and may contain errors. Read the full minutes for the official record.
**Procedural matters** – The meeting began with a report from the Democratic Officer on the emergency evacuation and domestic procedures. The minutes of the Miscellaneous Licensing Committee meeting of 15 August 2025 were corrected to show a start time of 10:30 am (instead of 10:00 am) and were approved after a motion by Councillor Cador and seconded by Councillor Pascoe. In accordance with the Local Government Act 1972, the press and public were excluded from consideration of items that involved exempt information about individuals. The Chairman noted an urgent item and the Committee took a comfort break from 11:48 am to 11:58 am; Councillor Batters left the meeting at 11:20 am.
**Refusals of new licences** – The Committee refused two applications for Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle driver licences. Applicant WD207, who was absent but submitted a written statement, was denied on the basis that the applicant was not a “fit and proper” person, citing a caution for an offence and failure to attend the hearing. Applicant WD209, who attended with a representative, was also refused. The Committee considered medical reports, a confirmed DVLA Group 2 fitness, but placed greater weight on nine penalty points for three driving offences and concluded that the applicant did not meet the “fit and proper” standard required for public safety.
**Renewal with conditions** – Applicant CD287 applied for renewal of an existing licence and attended the hearing. The Committee agreed to grant the renewal subject to the receipt of satisfactory stress‑echocardiogram and myocardial‑perfusion‑scan results, as recommended by a consultant cardiologist. The members judged that the additional medical testing was proportionate and that the licence could be issued provided the tests confirmed fitness for the role; any adverse findings would trigger a further hearing.
**Further refusal and overall outcome** – The final application considered was from W1D166, who was not present. The Committee refused the licence, citing a recent conviction and caution for a violent offence, six penalty points for speed‑limit breaches, and an ongoing suspended prison sentence. Guidance on the Council’s suitability guidelines and HR Safeguarding advice supported the decision. In total, the Committee approved the corrected minutes, excluded the public for sensitive items, refused three new licence applications, and granted one renewal conditional on additional medical evidence.
Attendance
14 of 15 members present
Decisions
Minutes of Miscellaneous Licensing Committee recorded and signed
The council confirmed that the August 15, 2025 Miscellaneous Licensing Committee meeting minutes were correctly recorded, will be signed by the chairman, and the start time should be listed as 10:30 am.
Exclusion of press and public from consideration of certain business
The council decided to keep the press and public out of the meeting while they discuss certain matters that contain protected information.
Refusal of Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Licence for Applicant WD207
The council refused WD207’s request for a hackney carriage and private‑hire driver licence because they decided the applicant was not a fit and proper person.
Refusal of Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Licence for Applicant WD209
The council refused WD209’s request for a taxi and private‑hire driver licence because they decided the applicant is not a fit and proper person.
Conditional grant of renewal for Applicant CD287
The council will renew CD287’s hackney carriage and private‑hire driver licence, but only if they provide satisfactory stress‑echo and myocardial‑perfusion scan results.
Refusal of Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Licence for Applicant W1D166
The council refused the applicant’s licence because their criminal convictions, cautions, penalty points and a pending suspended prison sentence make them unfit.
Related meetings
Adjacent Miscellaneous Licensing Committee meetings:
Other meetings within a week
- Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Leadership Board — Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Leadership Board - 5 September 2025 (5 Sept 2025)
- Appeals Committee — Appeals Committee - 8 September 2025 (8 Sept 2025)
- Committee in Common between Cornwall Health and Wellbeing Board and the Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Integrated Care Partnership — Committee in Common between Cornwall Health and Wellbeing Board and the Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Integrated Care Partnership - 9 September 2025 (9 Sept 2025)
- Licensing Act Sub Committee — Licensing Act Sub Committee - 10 September 2025 (10 Sept 2025)
- Cornwall Pension Fund Local Pension Board — Cornwall Pension Fund Local Pension Board - 10 September 2025 (10 Sept 2025)
- Standing Advisory Council on Religious Education — Standing Advisory Council on Religious Education - 11 September 2025 (11 Sept 2025)