Standing Advisory Council on Religious Education - 11 September 2025
Key Takeaways
- •Councillor Thomas was elected Chairman and Lee Moscato was elected Vice Chairman of Cornwall SACRE.
- •The committee approved the 2025-2026 budget spending intentions, with £10,000 additional funding secured for the Agreed Syllabus Conference and Launch (less than the £15,000 requested).
- •The new Agreed Syllabus 2025-2030 was successfully launched with high attendance and engagement, featuring a more inclusive religion and world view approach rather than traditional faith-by-faith teaching.
- •The syllabus is being used across Cornwall, Plymouth, Torbay and Devon SACRE areas and is available on the Cornwall Council website.
- •Members expressed concerns about the lack of OFSTED inspection of collective worship in schools and the difficulty in defining what constitutes good quality collective worship.
This summary was generated by AI and may contain errors. Read the full minutes for the official record.
The meeting opened with the election of the Committee’s leadership. Mike Heron moved, and Patrick Buckley seconded, that Councillor Thomas be elected Chairman; the motion was carried and Councillor Thomas thanked members. A second motion, moved by Nicola Bonell and seconded by Mike Heron, elected Lee Moscato as Vice‑Chairman, and members congratulated him in his absence. The Clerk confirmed that two new representatives had joined the SACRE – Pat McGovern (replacing Maggie Thompson) and Mary Judkins – both serving Group A as representatives of the Roman Catholic Church and Independent Churches respectively, and the Chairman welcomed the newly appointed councillors.
The Committee approved the minutes of the 20 March 2025 meeting, signed by the Chairman, and noted that no public questions or statements had been received. A report on the 2025‑2026 budget, presented by the Senior Education Effectiveness Officer, highlighted that the figures reflected the financial position as of 17 June 2025 due to a postponed meeting date. Discussion clarified that the budget totals were fixed, though allocations within the budget could be adjusted, and that an additional £15 000 request for the Agreed Syllabus Conference had been partially funded (£10 000 from the Local Authority plus £8 125 from Learn Teach Lead RE and the Cornwall Association of Secondary Heads). It was resolved, on motion by Ron Ede and seconded by Councillor Ashton, that SACRE would spend the allocated funds in line with the SACRE Action Plan and approved the spending intentions set out in paragraph 11.1.
The Consultants gave a verbal update on the May 2025 Agreed Syllabus Conference and Launch. Members reported strong attendance and positive feedback, noting that the new 2025‑2030 syllabus builds on the previous version while incorporating local Cornwall references and a broader religion‑and‑world‑view approach consistent with national policy. Issues raised included the need to disseminate the syllabus to schools that missed the launch, to clarify legal obligations for academy schools, and to provide ongoing support for schools that require assistance. The Committee agreed to a short presentation on the syllabus at the next meeting and expressed concern that some teachers, particularly in Multi‑Academy Trusts, lacked flexibility in curriculum delivery.
Finally, the Senior Education Effectiveness Officer presented the SACRE annual cycle of Assess‑Plan‑Do‑Review and proposed several next steps: member participation in NASACRE self‑evaluation toolkits (to be submitted by September 2025), formation of small working groups with representation from each of the four SACRE groups, and development of a new SACRE website. Members expressed general support and urged prompt commencement of the work. It was also resolved that the updated Action Plan and its budget implications, as outlined in the consultants’ report, be accepted by the Committee. The meeting concluded with the agreement that a more detailed report with specific recommendations will be presented at the next meeting for further discussion and voting.
Attendance
2 of 5 members present
Decisions
Election of Chairman
Mike Heron proposed, and Patrick Buckley seconded, the election of Councillor Thomas as chairman, and the council approved it.
Election of Vice Chairman
The council voted to elect Lee Moscato as Vice Chairman.
Approval of Minutes (20 March 2025)
The council approved the March 20, 2025 meeting minutes as correct and asked the chairman to sign them.
Approval of FY 2025-2026 Budget Spending Intentions
The council approved the FY 2025‑2026 budget spending plan, requiring the funds to be used as outlined in the action plan.
Agreement to Updated Action Plan (Report Consideration)
The council approved the updated action plan after considering the report, following a motion by John Keast and seconded by Patrick McGovern.
Agreement to Budget Implications of Updated Action Plan
The council agreed, after a motion by John Keast and seconded by Noreen Brosnan, to accept the budget impact of the updated action plan for the April 2025 budget.
Authorization for Cornwall Council to View Full Minutes for Item RE/120
The council approved a request by John Keast (seconded by Patrick McGovern) to view the complete minutes for item RE/120.
Related meetings
Adjacent Standing Advisory Council on Religious Education meetings:
Other meetings within a week
- Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Leadership Board — Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Leadership Board - 5 September 2025 (5 Sept 2025)
- Appeals Committee — Appeals Committee - 8 September 2025 (8 Sept 2025)
- Committee in Common between Cornwall Health and Wellbeing Board and the Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Integrated Care Partnership — Committee in Common between Cornwall Health and Wellbeing Board and the Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Integrated Care Partnership - 9 September 2025 (9 Sept 2025)
- Licensing Act Sub Committee — Licensing Act Sub Committee - 10 September 2025 (10 Sept 2025)
- Cornwall Pension Fund Local Pension Board — Cornwall Pension Fund Local Pension Board - 10 September 2025 (10 Sept 2025)
- Miscellaneous Licensing Committee — Miscellaneous Licensing Committee - 12 September 2025 (12 Sept 2025)